These Three Remain: Fitzwilliam Darcy, Gentleman
15 journalers for this copy...
Aus William Shakespeares A Midsummer Night's Dream [I, 1]:
LYSANDER
Ah me! for aught that I could ever read,
Could ever hear by tale or history,
The course of true love never did run smooth:
But either it was different in blood,—
HERMIA
O cross! Too high to be enthrall'd to low!
LYSANDER
Or else misgraffed in respect of years;—
HERMIA
O spite! Too old to be engag'd to young!
LYSANDER
Or else it stood upon the choice of friends:
HERMIA
O hell! to choose love by another's eye!
LYSANDER
Or, if there were a sympathy in choice,
War, death, or sickness, did lay siege to it,
Making it momentary as a sound,
Swift as a shadow, short as any dream;
1. Leseschaf (NRW)
2. Annieselan (Hessen)
3. MrBennet (Hessen)
4. elhamisabel (Hessen)
5. tourvel (NRW)
6. J-sama (Sachsen)
7. greeneyemoony (NRW)
8. Tiikeri (Schleswig-Holstein)
9. DA-Cameron (Baden-Württemberg)
10. dschinny (Hamburg)
11. Rochester74 (Hessen)
12. Stella-del-Nord (Niedersachsen)
13. BerlinBookworm (Berlin)
14. erinacea (Berlin)
15. nach Hause
10.9.: travelling again (at last - sorry for the delay)
And there´s something else which makes me wonder: didn´t Lizzie & Darcy meet again at Lady Catherines dinner? I must grab my volume of P&P and read this part again.
Sorry for criticizing so much, but I was a bit disappointed. But only a bit, I really liked to read the three books which told P&P again from Darcy´s point of view. Thank you for letting me share these bookrings, urfin! I had a great time reading them.
Released 15 yrs ago (9/18/2008 UTC) at -- Per Post/Persönliche Weitergabe--, Hessen Germany
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
The book is on it´s journey to MrBennet!
Update 10.10.08:
I liked this 3rd volume much better than the second. Indeed, the author seems in need of the original story to lean on, then it's not too bad (whereas the ideas of a story she developed before were not at all convincing).
I also did not find Darcy foolish in his lovesickness - though Ms Aidan becomes rather repetitive at times. He had to accomplish his fundamental change in character somehow, and I find this concept quite cute. Dy's story however is bullshit, just as some other parts of the story (like how Darcy manages to find Lydia).
Well - all in all quite an entertaining read.
Next week, I'll take the book to the Frankfurt MeetUp and hand it on to elhamisabel.
I've skipped part 2, I've only heard negative things about it anyway.
Let's see how bad this one is.
Negative: Urgh! (JE #11) - this is no different to that first one. I was so annoyed about the blatant mistakes and awful wording after the first 10 pages, that I gave up. I'm not wasting my precious time on this shit.
Already contacted tourvel for the address.
8.11.2008
Ich habe das Buch eben beendet. Auch ich finde den dritten Band wieder besser, aber ich finde auch, dass Darcy zuviel in Elisabeth-Gedanken schwelgt. Diese Teile fand ich irgendwann etwas nervig. Wenn ich so etwas lesen möchte lese ich meine Barbara Cartlands *g*
Ich schließe mich den anderen auch insofern an, dass ich mir Darcy nicht wirklich so vorstellen kann wie er beschrieben wird; dass Darcy alles seiner Schwester erzählt; dass diese Agenten-Geschichte passt; diese Sylvanie-Geschichte *urks*...
Ich habe mich nicht durch das Buch gequält, aber ich finde nicht, dass Aidan dem Darcy-Part gerecht wird. Ich habe das Buch ähnlich konsumiert, wie eins von diesen Cartlands und hatte insofern schon ein gewisses Vergnügen :-)
Released 15 yrs ago (11/21/2008 UTC) at -- Per Post geschickt / Persönlich weitergegeben --, Nordrhein-Westfalen Germany
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
Macht sich endlich auf dem Weg zu J-Sama.
May take a while to read - so don't worry
Its getting better though. From their meeting at Rosings the story is getting some flow. Well you know how the story turns out but still you feel with them. The end was rather rushed in my opinion. My feeling was, that the pages too much at the beginning were missing in the end. An epilogue to give a view into there life after the marriage would have been interesting. But well, you can't have everything. Thank you for the ring an the patience.
Released 15 yrs ago (1/22/2009 UTC) at -- Per Post geschickt/ Persönlich weitergegeben --, Sachsen Germany
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
Today, the third part finally continues its journey.
Thank you for the ring
Released 15 yrs ago (3/5/2009 UTC) at -- Per Post geschickt / Persönlich weitergegeben --, Nordrhein-Westfalen Germany
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
Zu Tiikeri weitergeschickt
I also liked Dy as a character but all this stuff about treason and spying was as ridicilous as the Sylvanie-part of the story.
Altogether it was a pleasant read and I thank you very much, Urfin, for sharing the books. This one will be on its way to DA-Cameron soon.
3. 6. 2009:
This is - in my opinion - the best book of the series. Georgiana bore more resemblance to her counterpart in P&P, Darcy's behaviour was quite believable. So was Bingley's development (albeit not quite authentic). And Dy - he's wonderful!
I could have done without Sylvaine, but at least she had a minor role here.
Released 14 yrs ago (5/31/2009 UTC) at Ditzingen, Baden-Württemberg Germany
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
The book is on it's way to the next reader. :-)
6.6.09 Finished. I think of all three books I liked the first one best, then this one and the second part last. Darcy was way too romantic and I kept wondering how it would have been if the book had been written by a man. A seperate book about Dy would be interesting, I really liked him. Will send it on asap.
My advice: read the first book, get a good summery of the second book and finally read the third book.
This book will be send to Stella-del-Nord together with the second one next week.
Nachtrag:
Nachdem ich Band 1 verschlungen und Band 2 mehr oder weniger ausgelassen habe, war ich sehr gespannt auf Band 3 und das Wiedersehen unserer beiden Protagonisten. Ich wurde nicht enttäuscht und bekam eine sehr bewegende Liebesgeschichte zu lesen.
Ob allerdings Darcys Wandlung vom Saulus zum Paulus tatsächlich sooo schnell erfolgt ist und er monatelang als liebeskranker Romeo unterwegs war, kann ich mir nicht wirklich vorstellen. Trotzdem absolut lesenswert.
Das Buch reist zusammen mit Band 2 weiter zu BerlinBookworm. Viel Spaß bei der Lektüre!
Released 13 yrs ago (10/23/2010 UTC) at
CONTROLLED RELEASE NOTES:
I still enjoyed reading those parts where Darcy and Elisabeth interact. I will also check out the other spin-off novels that were written on Darcy.
I got the vague feeling that this story's Darcy doesn't quite match Austen's hero, but to me it didn't really matter. What's fanfic for, if not to play around with the characters? :p
I found it hilarious to watch Darcy squirm under his cousin's scrutiny, and I had ever so much fun playacting the drunken confession to Dy (sometimes I was giggling so hard I couldn't get a word out) or Lady Catherine's final confrontation.
Aidan's explanation for the colonel's behaviour at Rosings cleared up a few questions of mine, and though I thought Darcy's interpretations of some of Elizabeth's comments a bit far-fetched, it's not entirely unreasable considering he's wildly in love at that point and likely to hear what he hopes and expects to hear.
I loved how Georgiana, Dy and Bingley each played their different parts in Darcy's self-reformation. Actually, I considered the whole thing exceedingly well executed. Other than P&P, I think this is not so much a romantic tale than a story of loyalty and redemption. It's simply that the main focus is a different one.
Though I didn't much care for Darcy's friend Dy in parts 1 or 2, I somehow grew to like him in this book, long before he unmasked himself. I even came to regret the fact that Aidan didn't stick to writing a snarky Victorian spy novel instead. From what's there in these three books, it would have been awesome! :D
To add some criticism, I felt that Wickham and all the thoughts, conversations and dealings regarding him somehow didn't fit into the story. It's not only that I didn't like him, for obvious reasons, but that he was rather clumsily dealt with and treated like a cardboard character that was only included because he was in the original novel.
This is a book I just might be tempted to buy at some time (ignoring the two previous parts, of course).
@Urfin: Thanks for letting me participate in the ring! I'll be handing it back to you at next week's meet-up.
And thank you all for your (different:) JEs :o)